Celtic Are Not a Charity Shop

Martin O'Neill has made it plain. West Ham want Arne Engels. Celtic don't want to sell him cheap. That's the story, and it's a good one — because it shows a Scottish club refusing to roll over the moment English money comes sniffing around.

O'Neill confirmed the bid failed to meet Celtic's valuation. No drama. No theatrics. Just a manager protecting his club's asset and saying so publicly. That takes confidence. It also takes an understanding of what Engels is worth in this market.

West Ham Tried It On

This is standard Premier League behaviour. Go in low. Hope the seller blinks. Dress it up as a "serious offer." Celtic didn't blink.

West Ham know what they're doing. They're not naive. They submitted a bid that didn't match the asking price because that's how these negotiations start. The problem is O'Neill has called it out in public, which means Celtic aren't panicking and aren't desperate. That's a bad sign for West Ham if they genuinely want this deal done.

Engels is clearly someone Celtic rate highly enough to put a firm price on. O'Neill didn't hedge. He didn't say the offer was "close" or "in the right direction." He said it didn't meet the valuation. Full stop.

West Ham need to come back with proper money or find someone else.

Johnston Is a Different Conversation

O'Neill also confirmed Everton's interest in right-back Alistair Johnston. This one feels further along in the sense that it's being spoken about openly. A manager naming a specific club rarely happens by accident.

Everton have had a rough few years. They're rebuilding. A reliable, mobile right-back makes sense for what they're trying to do. Johnston has been solid for Celtic and O'Neill clearly rates him — which is exactly why the confirmation of Everton's interest is interesting. O'Neill isn't dismissing it.

What he hasn't done is say Celtic want to sell. There's a difference between acknowledging interest and opening the door. O'Neill seems to be doing the former. Celtic hold the cards on this one too.

Celtic Are Playing This Right

Some clubs fold the moment a Premier League side calls. They get dazzled by the badge or the broadcast money and end up undervaluing their own players. Celtic, under O'Neill's current approach, are not doing that.

Two separate enquiries. Two separate players. Both handled the same way — calmly and publicly, which signals strength. "We know what they're worth. Come correct or don't come at all."

That's the right attitude. Celtic have a history of developing players and selling them well when the time is right. The discipline to hold a valuation matters. The moment you drop your price because a big English club is interested, you've already lost the negotiation.

What Happens Next

West Ham will either increase their offer for Engels or move on to the next name on their list. If they come back closer to Celtic's number, this gets done. If not, Engels stays in Glasgow — which Celtic would not be upset about.

The Johnston situation with Everton feels like it has more runway. Everton's interest has been confirmed publicly by the Celtic manager himself. That's not nothing. Whether a formal bid has been submitted or matches Celtic's expectations is still unclear, but the conversation is live.

Celtic are in control of both situations right now. They don't need to sell. They're not under pressure. And O'Neill is making sure everyone knows it.

Our Verdict

Celtic are running a tight ship in this window. West Ham got a public rejection. Everton are being watched carefully. O'Neill is not here to make life easy for Premier League clubs who think Scottish football is a discount aisle. Good. Hold the line.

---
Photo by [Franco Monsalvo](https://www.pexels.com/@franco-monsalvo-252430633) on [Pexels](https://www.pexels.com/photo/exciting-football-match-action-shot-on-field-32285166/)